下载App
资质规则
旅行
账户
Vania I
Tourist Trap or Genuine Experience?
花宫娜香水工厂的点评
点评：We took the factory tour and, of course, the sales pitch. 🙂
Somehow, we believed we were buying genuine perfumes with 25% perfume oil, just as the guide proudly explained.
Looking back, we should have paid attention to three things:
There were no workers and no production taking place in the factory—only salespeople.
The fragrance on the test strips was surprisingly weak, even immediately after being sprayed.
Our tour representatives received complimentary gifts from the factory.
The result?
Once we got home, we discovered that the fragrance disappeared after 30 minutes at most—far from the guide's promise that 3–4 drops would last all day.
Because Fragonard is a company with more than 100 years of history, I assumed this couldn't possibly reflect the company's standards. I thought perhaps we had simply encountered an internal issue or poor quality control and staff taking advantage.
So I contacted the company, provided all the requested information, including photos and proof of purchase.
Their response: "Everything is correct. The reason may be the way your skin perceives the fragrance"
An interesting explanation, especially considering that the same thing happened to everyone in our group who bought:)
Conclusion: I leave it to yourselves
Somehow, we believed we were buying genuine perfumes with 25% perfume oil, just as the guide proudly explained.
Looking back, we should have paid attention to three things:
There were no workers and no production taking place in the factory—only salespeople.
The fragrance on the test strips was surprisingly weak, even immediately after being sprayed.
Our tour representatives received complimentary gifts from the factory.
The result?
Once we got home, we discovered that the fragrance disappeared after 30 minutes at most—far from the guide's promise that 3–4 drops would last all day.
Because Fragonard is a company with more than 100 years of history, I assumed this couldn't possibly reflect the company's standards. I thought perhaps we had simply encountered an internal issue or poor quality control and staff taking advantage.
So I contacted the company, provided all the requested information, including photos and proof of purchase.
Their response: "Everything is correct. The reason may be the way your skin perceives the fragrance"
An interesting explanation, especially considering that the same thing happened to everyone in our group who bought:)
Conclusion: I leave it to yourselves
翻译：我们参观了工厂，当然也听了他们的推销。🙂
不知怎么的，我们竟然相信自己买到的是正品香水，香精油含量高达25%，就像导游自豪地宣称的那样。
现在回想起来，我们应该注意以下三点：
工厂里没有工人，也没有生产活动——只有销售人员。
试用装的香味出奇地淡，即使刚喷上去也是如此。
我们的导游收到了工厂赠送的礼品。
结果呢？
回家后，我们发现香味最多只能持续30分钟——与导游承诺的3-4滴就能持续一整天的说法相去甚远。
因为Fragonard是一家拥有百年历史的公司，我当时觉得这不可能反映出公司的正常水平。我以为我们只是遇到了内部问题，或者质量控制不严，有人趁机牟利。
于是，我联系了公司，提供了他们要求的所有信息，包括照片和购买凭证。
他们的回复：“一切正常。原因可能是你的皮肤对香水的感知方式不同。”
这个解释很有意思，尤其是考虑到我们组里所有购买的人都遇到了同样的情况:)
结论：就留给你们自己去探索吧。
不知怎么的，我们竟然相信自己买到的是正品香水，香精油含量高达25%，就像导游自豪地宣称的那样。
现在回想起来，我们应该注意以下三点：
工厂里没有工人，也没有生产活动——只有销售人员。
试用装的香味出奇地淡，即使刚喷上去也是如此。
我们的导游收到了工厂赠送的礼品。
结果呢？
回家后，我们发现香味最多只能持续30分钟——与导游承诺的3-4滴就能持续一整天的说法相去甚远。
因为Fragonard是一家拥有百年历史的公司，我当时觉得这不可能反映出公司的正常水平。我以为我们只是遇到了内部问题，或者质量控制不严，有人趁机牟利。
于是，我联系了公司，提供了他们要求的所有信息，包括照片和购买凭证。
他们的回复：“一切正常。原因可能是你的皮肤对香水的感知方式不同。”
这个解释很有意思，尤其是考虑到我们组里所有购买的人都遇到了同样的情况:)
结论：就留给你们自己去探索吧。
© 2026 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
