下载App
资质规则
旅行
账户
D2814TFdavidh
Great summit day and an unforgettable supra, but felt like a second-class client
Mountain Freaks的点评
点评：Logistically, our Kazbek expedition with Mountain Freaks met its main goal, and everyone who was given the chance made it to the summit. The actual summit day was an incredible experience, and the final traditional supra with live music and great food was a fantastic celebration. Huge credit goes to our local guide on summit day, who was an absolute professional—he kept a great pace, prioritized safety, and created a brilliant atmosphere on the rope. He completely saved the mountain experience for us. I also appreciate that when push came to shove, the agency managed to deliver rental replacement boots straight to the hut. However, as someone who owns and operates a travel agency specializing in high-altitude trekking and safari expeditions, the overall experience left a very bitter taste in my mouth. If I offered my own clients this level of service and treated them this way, I would be deeply ashamed.
It all started long before departure. The group chat ran almost exclusively in Polish. An English message would pop up once in a blue moon just for show, but the actual ratio was easily 20-to-1 in favor of Polish, so I had to translate almost everything myself. Less than two weeks before departure, Olek posted in the chat (in Polish again) that the horses wouldn't stop at AltiHut anymore and would carry gear straight to Betlemi. When I decided to carry my own gear to avoid the confusion, I received a pushy email telling me I'd be exhausted and should reconsider paying for the horse. Instead of an apology for the last-minute logistical changes, it was just pressure to buy extra services. I honestly considered canceling the trip right then, but my flights and trek were already paid for.
The pricing structure is another major trick. The agency advertises a very low price on their website, but it’s a pure marketing gimmick built on a stripped-down "walk up the mountain and sleep in a tent" concept. Transporting gear by mules costs extra, staying in huts costs extra, and all expedition food is out of pocket. Once you arrive, you realize that every single client ends up buying these extra services anyway. When you add up what you actually spend, you arrive at the same or higher cost than serious agencies that include mules, huts, and meals in their upfront price and treat you fairly from the start.
Once on the mountain, the overwhelmed leadership became painfully obvious. Nika, the agency owner, acted as the lead guide for a group of 24 people alongside three assistant guides. Despite having a team, trying to run the business, manage logistics, and play the main authority figure was clearly too much for one person. He was constantly irritated and led with a rigid military drill mindset. We didn't feel like paying clients; we felt like we were on a forced march. When I set a good pace early on and accidentally blended into another group, I saw such genuine anger and aggression in his eyes that I wanted to turn around and go home after the first 50 vertical meters. I am 46 years old and paying for a service—being treated like that just because a guide has an ego issue is completely unacceptable. The absurdity of his strictness was highlighted by the fact that other clients were making fun of him behind his back, mocking his overly stern behavior ("watch out, Nika is coming to lecture you again").
This lack of customer-centric care was evident everywhere. When the sole of my boot completely peeled off near AltiHut, I went to Nika in high stress to ask what we should do. Instead of a helpful answer, he just snapped at me to wait and keep walking. I walked for hours in complete uncertainty, thinking my expedition was over. They eventually arranged replacement boots from the rental shop, but why couldn't he just tell me right away: "Don't worry, replacement boots are coming up to the hut," and save me hours of unnecessary anxiety? When I pay for an expedition, I expect the guide—regardless of whether he likes me personally—to be the person who offers professional help, reassures me, and maintains a friendly attitude.
Safety standards were equally poor. Half the group didn't even know how to put crampons on, and nobody bothered to teach them before stepping onto the glacier. At one point, one client was actually crossing the glacier with crampons strapped over regular sneakers (trainers), and the guides didn't even blink. To top it off, while clients were under a strict ban on alcohol, the guides were drinking every single evening.
The absolute peak of insensitive and lazy leadership was their handling of one female client. After the acclimatization hike, she was flatly told she wouldn't be allowed to attempt summit day, simply because of her slower pace. Yet the staff capacity was clearly there—on several ropes, there were two guides assigned to a single line, so it wasn't a personnel shortage, but a total lack of willingness. Instead of discussing options, adjusting rope assignments, or giving her a chance to fight for her dream, they simply wrote her off. For someone who spends months training, investing significant money, and using valuable vacation time, being cut loose due to leadership laziness is an absolute client nightmare.
I know most people return home happy just to have reached the summit, caught up in the euphoria and forgetting all the flaws. But from the perspective of a travel industry professional and a paying customer, this operation was full of critical failures. If you don't speak Polish and expect international client standards, transparent pricing, and leadership partnership rather than ego trips, I would never voluntarily recommend this agency.
It all started long before departure. The group chat ran almost exclusively in Polish. An English message would pop up once in a blue moon just for show, but the actual ratio was easily 20-to-1 in favor of Polish, so I had to translate almost everything myself. Less than two weeks before departure, Olek posted in the chat (in Polish again) that the horses wouldn't stop at AltiHut anymore and would carry gear straight to Betlemi. When I decided to carry my own gear to avoid the confusion, I received a pushy email telling me I'd be exhausted and should reconsider paying for the horse. Instead of an apology for the last-minute logistical changes, it was just pressure to buy extra services. I honestly considered canceling the trip right then, but my flights and trek were already paid for.
The pricing structure is another major trick. The agency advertises a very low price on their website, but it’s a pure marketing gimmick built on a stripped-down "walk up the mountain and sleep in a tent" concept. Transporting gear by mules costs extra, staying in huts costs extra, and all expedition food is out of pocket. Once you arrive, you realize that every single client ends up buying these extra services anyway. When you add up what you actually spend, you arrive at the same or higher cost than serious agencies that include mules, huts, and meals in their upfront price and treat you fairly from the start.
Once on the mountain, the overwhelmed leadership became painfully obvious. Nika, the agency owner, acted as the lead guide for a group of 24 people alongside three assistant guides. Despite having a team, trying to run the business, manage logistics, and play the main authority figure was clearly too much for one person. He was constantly irritated and led with a rigid military drill mindset. We didn't feel like paying clients; we felt like we were on a forced march. When I set a good pace early on and accidentally blended into another group, I saw such genuine anger and aggression in his eyes that I wanted to turn around and go home after the first 50 vertical meters. I am 46 years old and paying for a service—being treated like that just because a guide has an ego issue is completely unacceptable. The absurdity of his strictness was highlighted by the fact that other clients were making fun of him behind his back, mocking his overly stern behavior ("watch out, Nika is coming to lecture you again").
This lack of customer-centric care was evident everywhere. When the sole of my boot completely peeled off near AltiHut, I went to Nika in high stress to ask what we should do. Instead of a helpful answer, he just snapped at me to wait and keep walking. I walked for hours in complete uncertainty, thinking my expedition was over. They eventually arranged replacement boots from the rental shop, but why couldn't he just tell me right away: "Don't worry, replacement boots are coming up to the hut," and save me hours of unnecessary anxiety? When I pay for an expedition, I expect the guide—regardless of whether he likes me personally—to be the person who offers professional help, reassures me, and maintains a friendly attitude.
Safety standards were equally poor. Half the group didn't even know how to put crampons on, and nobody bothered to teach them before stepping onto the glacier. At one point, one client was actually crossing the glacier with crampons strapped over regular sneakers (trainers), and the guides didn't even blink. To top it off, while clients were under a strict ban on alcohol, the guides were drinking every single evening.
The absolute peak of insensitive and lazy leadership was their handling of one female client. After the acclimatization hike, she was flatly told she wouldn't be allowed to attempt summit day, simply because of her slower pace. Yet the staff capacity was clearly there—on several ropes, there were two guides assigned to a single line, so it wasn't a personnel shortage, but a total lack of willingness. Instead of discussing options, adjusting rope assignments, or giving her a chance to fight for her dream, they simply wrote her off. For someone who spends months training, investing significant money, and using valuable vacation time, being cut loose due to leadership laziness is an absolute client nightmare.
I know most people return home happy just to have reached the summit, caught up in the euphoria and forgetting all the flaws. But from the perspective of a travel industry professional and a paying customer, this operation was full of critical failures. If you don't speak Polish and expect international client standards, transparent pricing, and leadership partnership rather than ego trips, I would never voluntarily recommend this agency.
翻译：从后勤保障的角度来看，我们与Mountain Freaks共同组织的卡兹别克山攀登活动实现了主要目标——所有有机会参加的人员都成功登顶。登顶当天真是一次难忘的经历，而随后举行的伴有现场音乐与美味佳肴的传统宴席则是一场极棒的庆祝活动。特别要表扬的是当天带队的当地向导，他绝对堪称专业典范：他掌控着合适的行进节奏，始终把安全放在首位，还在队伍中营造了极佳的氛围。他彻底提升了我们的登山体验。我也很感激在紧要关头，旅行社设法把替换用的登山靴直接送到了山屋。不过，作为一名经营着专门提供高海拔徒步及探险旅行的旅行社的人，这次经历给我留下了极其不好的印象。如果我对自己的客户提供这种水平的服务，并以这种方式对待他们，我会感到无比羞愧。一切都始于出发前很久。群聊里几乎全是波兰语。偶尔会出现一条英文消息，但那纯粹是做做样子而已；实际上，波兰语消息的比例高达20比1，因此我几乎得把所有内容都自己翻译。出发前不到两周，奥莱克又在群里发消息（依旧用的是波兰语），说马队不会再在AltiHut停留，而是会直接把装备运到Betlemi。就在那时，我决定自己携带装备，免得出现混乱。我收到了一封咄咄逼人的邮件，说我肯定会筋疲力尽，因此应该重新考虑是否要花钱雇马匹。这封邮件非但没有为临时的安排变动道歉，反而施压让我购买额外的服务。说实话，我当时真想取消这次行程，不过机票和徒步费用都早已支付完毕了。
定价机制也是另一个套路。这家旅行社在其网站上宣传的价格低得离谱。但这纯粹是一个营销噱头，其基础就是“登上山顶后在帐篷里过夜”这种简单至极的概念。雇佣骡子来运输装备需要额外付费，入住山间小屋也要另外花钱，所有的探险食品都得自理费用。等真正到了那里，你会发现几乎所有客户最终都会购买这些附加服务。把实际花费加起来后，总费用其实与那些提供骡子服务、山间小屋等配套服务的正规旅行社所收的费用相当，甚至更高。他们的预定价中已包含了餐食费用，从一开始便公平对待每一位游客。
一旦登上山后，管理层的力不从心便暴露无遗。旅行社老板尼卡亲自担任24人团队的领队，身边还有三名助理导游。尽管有团队协助，但要同时打理业务、处理后勤事务并充当最高决策者，对一个人来说显然负担过重。他总是显得烦躁易怒，行事方式也刻板得像在执行军事训练指令。我们并不觉得自己是付费客户；反而感觉像是在被迫赶路。一开始我保持了较快的节奏，结果不小心跟上了另一组人。那时我从他眼中看到了毫不掩饰的愤怒与敌意，以至于才爬了50米我就想转身回家。我今年46岁，花钱购买服务——仅仅因为导游有自负心理问题就遭到这种对待，实在是不可接受。他的刻板严厉简直荒谬至极——其他客户都在背后嘲笑他，讥讽他那过于严苛的举止（“小心，尼卡又要来训话了”）。
这种以客户为中心意识的缺失随处可见。有一次，我的靴底在AltiHut附近完全脱落了，我心急如焚地去找尼卡，询问该怎么办。然而他并未给出任何有用的建议，只是厉声命令我等着并继续前进。我怀着极度不安的心情走了好几个小时，以为这次探险要宣告结束了。后来他们终于从租赁店安排了替换的靴子，但为什么他不能立刻告诉我：“别担心，替换的靴子马上就会送到小屋来”，从而免去我数小时的无谓焦虑呢？当我花钱参加探险活动时，我期望向导——不管他个人是否喜欢我——都能提供专业的帮助、安抚我的情绪，并保持友善的态度。安全标准同样糟糕。有一半的团员甚至不知道如何佩戴冰爪，而在踏上冰川之前也无人教导他们。有一次，有个客户竟然穿着普通运动鞋并绑上冰爪就横穿冰川，而向导们对此也毫无反应。更离谱的是，虽然明文禁止客户饮酒，但向导们却每晚都喝酒。这种麻木不仁又敷衍了事的领导方式，在他们对待一位女客户的过程中体现到了极致。在适应性徒步之后，她被直接告知：由于她的行进速度较慢，因此不被允许参加登顶行动。然而，工作人员其实是充足的——好几条攀爬绳上都配有两名向导来负责同一条线路，所以并非人手不足，而是完全缺乏责任心。他们既没有商量其他可行方案，也没有重新调整人员的配置。要么是不给她为梦想拼搏的机会，要么就是直接将她淘汰。对于那些花费数月时间训练、投入大量资金并牺牲宝贵假期的人来说，因为管理层的懈怠而被淘汰简直是一场噩梦般的经历。
我知道大多数人能成功登顶后都会心满意足地回家，沉浸在胜利的喜悦中，从而忽略了所有不足之处。但作为一名旅游行业从业者和付费客户，从我的角度来看……这次合作充满了严重的问题。如果你不会说波兰语，却又期望得到符合国际标准的客户服务、透明的定价体系，以及真正以合作伙伴关系为导向的领导方式而非自大自负的行为，那我绝对不会主动推荐这家机构。
定价机制也是另一个套路。这家旅行社在其网站上宣传的价格低得离谱。但这纯粹是一个营销噱头，其基础就是“登上山顶后在帐篷里过夜”这种简单至极的概念。雇佣骡子来运输装备需要额外付费，入住山间小屋也要另外花钱，所有的探险食品都得自理费用。等真正到了那里，你会发现几乎所有客户最终都会购买这些附加服务。把实际花费加起来后，总费用其实与那些提供骡子服务、山间小屋等配套服务的正规旅行社所收的费用相当，甚至更高。他们的预定价中已包含了餐食费用，从一开始便公平对待每一位游客。
一旦登上山后，管理层的力不从心便暴露无遗。旅行社老板尼卡亲自担任24人团队的领队，身边还有三名助理导游。尽管有团队协助，但要同时打理业务、处理后勤事务并充当最高决策者，对一个人来说显然负担过重。他总是显得烦躁易怒，行事方式也刻板得像在执行军事训练指令。我们并不觉得自己是付费客户；反而感觉像是在被迫赶路。一开始我保持了较快的节奏，结果不小心跟上了另一组人。那时我从他眼中看到了毫不掩饰的愤怒与敌意，以至于才爬了50米我就想转身回家。我今年46岁，花钱购买服务——仅仅因为导游有自负心理问题就遭到这种对待，实在是不可接受。他的刻板严厉简直荒谬至极——其他客户都在背后嘲笑他，讥讽他那过于严苛的举止（“小心，尼卡又要来训话了”）。
这种以客户为中心意识的缺失随处可见。有一次，我的靴底在AltiHut附近完全脱落了，我心急如焚地去找尼卡，询问该怎么办。然而他并未给出任何有用的建议，只是厉声命令我等着并继续前进。我怀着极度不安的心情走了好几个小时，以为这次探险要宣告结束了。后来他们终于从租赁店安排了替换的靴子，但为什么他不能立刻告诉我：“别担心，替换的靴子马上就会送到小屋来”，从而免去我数小时的无谓焦虑呢？当我花钱参加探险活动时，我期望向导——不管他个人是否喜欢我——都能提供专业的帮助、安抚我的情绪，并保持友善的态度。安全标准同样糟糕。有一半的团员甚至不知道如何佩戴冰爪，而在踏上冰川之前也无人教导他们。有一次，有个客户竟然穿着普通运动鞋并绑上冰爪就横穿冰川，而向导们对此也毫无反应。更离谱的是，虽然明文禁止客户饮酒，但向导们却每晚都喝酒。这种麻木不仁又敷衍了事的领导方式，在他们对待一位女客户的过程中体现到了极致。在适应性徒步之后，她被直接告知：由于她的行进速度较慢，因此不被允许参加登顶行动。然而，工作人员其实是充足的——好几条攀爬绳上都配有两名向导来负责同一条线路，所以并非人手不足，而是完全缺乏责任心。他们既没有商量其他可行方案，也没有重新调整人员的配置。要么是不给她为梦想拼搏的机会，要么就是直接将她淘汰。对于那些花费数月时间训练、投入大量资金并牺牲宝贵假期的人来说，因为管理层的懈怠而被淘汰简直是一场噩梦般的经历。
我知道大多数人能成功登顶后都会心满意足地回家，沉浸在胜利的喜悦中，从而忽略了所有不足之处。但作为一名旅游行业从业者和付费客户，从我的角度来看……这次合作充满了严重的问题。如果你不会说波兰语，却又期望得到符合国际标准的客户服务、透明的定价体系，以及真正以合作伙伴关系为导向的领导方式而非自大自负的行为，那我绝对不会主动推荐这家机构。
© 2026 Tripadvisor 版权所有。
部分照片由 VFM Leonardo 提供。
TripAdvisor公司对外部网站的内容一概不负责。优惠价格中不含税和其他费用。
ICP证：沪B2-20200433
沪ICP备20013175号
沪公网安备31010502005427号鹰程信息技术（上海）有限公司
